Beliefs are represented as neither maps nor sentences in the head: "Format blind" processing and specialization for theory of mind
نویسندگان
چکیده
Is the encoding of content and format necessary for representing beliefs? In three experiments using ”false-representation” tasks, we explored whether beliefs were processed like non-mental representations, under the assumption that non-mental representations require both content and format to be processed. First, beliefs were compared to sentences (linguistic medium) while keeping representational content constant, under either formatstressed (experiment 1) or content-stressed (experiment 2) conditions. Reaction time advantages for probes about belief over notes suggested belief processing did not include computational demands for specifying a linguistic format. In a third experiment comparing beliefs to maps (spatial medium), responses to probes about beliefs were faster than those to maps. These results suggest belief processing is ”format blind” such that specification of a representational medium is unnecessary. This difference in computational demands between mental and non-mental representations may be a source of specialization for the processing of mental states like belief.
منابع مشابه
Theory of mind and its neural mechanisms: A case study of Kurdish-Persian congenitally blind children in Ilam city
Introduction: Theory of mind is one of the most important aspects of cognitive faculty. The theory of mind is impaired in individuals who suffer from mental disorders like autistic children. The ‘autistic-like’ behaviors also have been reported in the congenitally blind children. This study was conducted to examine the presence or absence of theory of mind and its function in congen...
متن کاملVideo Art, Liminality, Mysticism
Liminality is a concept introduced by Victor Turner in the field of anthropology. According to him, myths can be designated as liminal phenomena which are neither here nor there; they are betwixt and between. Bill Viola is a video artist who has represented universal and pivotal dualities in his work, in a symbolic manner. The questions that this study tries to answer are as follows: What is th...
متن کاملFirst Language Activation during Second Language Lexical Processing in a Sentential Context
Lexicalization-patterns, the way words are mapped onto concepts, differ from one language to another. This study investigated the influence of first language (L1) lexicalization patterns on the processing of second language (L2) words in sentential contexts by both less proficient and more proficient Persian learners of English. The focus was on cases where two different senses of a polys...
متن کاملDynamic Mediation for Removing Language Comprehension Problems: A Psychological Support for Listening Comprehension Mental Processing
Dynamic Assessment is an approach to assessment within Applied Linguistics which is stemmed from Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory of mind, his concept of Zone of Proximal Development and Feuerstein's theory of Structural Cognitive Modifiability. This study is an attempt to pinpoint the sources of mental processing problems in listening comprehension and applies dynamic interventions to remove t...
متن کاملPlace Goes Wrong in Treating Mind-brain Relationship Clarifying why identity theory is neither reasonable nor a mere scientific problem in disguise
پِلِیس بر این باور است که مسائل فلسفی مرتبط با ماهیتِ نسبتِ میان ذهن و مغز، در نهایت بهنفعِ مادیگرایی -خصوصاً نظریه اینهمانیِ نوعی- کنار گذاشته یا منحل خواهند شد. او این مدعا را فرضیهای علمی و مستدل میداند. من در این مقاله نشان خواهم داد که ماجرا بهگونهای نیست که او میپندارد. اگر چه این متن، سراسر، حاوی جزئیات فراوانی در باب موضع پِلِیس است ولی به منظور فراهم آوردن بستری برای نقد، در ابتدا، روی...
متن کامل